Friday, October 29, 2010

Feedback Please!

I am hoping to start posting my reviews on cloth diapers this week.  Below is the criteria that I have come up with for the cloth diaper reviews.  I want to have set guidelines for the reviews so that you can compare certain diapers.  I welcome any and all feedback.  Would you like to see something else included in the review?  Should there be less criteria?  Do you like the scoring system?  Each review will be out of 30 points.  Is this too many?  There will also be a narrative at the end of every review with anything else that I would like to add.

Let me know what you think!!  The good, the bad, or the UGLY!!! 

My Scoring System

Price Per Diaper:

5 stars:  Under $10
4 stars:  Under $15
3 stars:  Under $20
2 stars:  Under $30
1 star:  Over $30


5 Stars:  No leaks
4 Stars:  Minimal leaks/ Possible User Error
3 Stars:  Some leaking for long naps or Night use
2 Stars:  Frequent Leaking
1 Star:  Always Leaks.


5 Stars:  Always able to find the perfect fit
4 Stars:  Mostly able to find the perfect fit
3 Stars:  Able to find a good fit but can be difficult
2 Stars:  Almost impossible to find a good fit
1 Star:  Fits Poorly

Ease of Use:

5 Stars:  Very easy to use
4 Stars:  Easy to use, but could be a little better
3 Stars:  Ok to use, but needs some modification
2 Stars:  Difficult to use
1 Star:  Impossible to use


5 Stars:  Washes very well, all stains come out easily
4 Stars:  Washes well, most stains come out easily
3 Stars:  Washes well, but some stains remain
2 Stars:  Very difficult to wash, difficult to get stains out
1 Star:  Does not wash well, many stains remain

Overall Performance:

5 Stars:  Very Impressed, Highly Recommended
4 Stars:  Impressed, Would Recommend
3 Stars:  Ok Diaper, Would recommend if other features are desireable
2 Stars:  Was not impressed, probably would not recommend
1 Star:  Did not like, would definitely not recommend

Total score From Above out of 30 possible.

Also included in every review...

Daddy’s Thoughts on this Diaper:

My Final Remarks:

Also included in the review will be photos of the diaper (outside, inside, close up of special features, and possibly a shot of my little one featuring the diaper).

And of course, not all of the above will be typed in every review!  I plan to post my scoring criteria in the header as a reference.  The actual review will just have the amount of stars (or whatever character I decide on) to represent the score for that topic and then the reason for that particular score.

No comments:

Post a Comment